Auron MacIntyre’s latest offering is very good, one of his best. It’s a thoughtful examination of the longstanding monarchism/republicanism/democracy debate on the dissident Right, focusing on the central issue: namely that, as Aristotle understood, the “form” must suit the “matter”. In the end, we get the system we deserve — and what makes the difference, as the Founders well understood, is the virtue of the people. (Which is in terrible shape).
One quibble: at the end of the episode, Macintyre lists some conditions for any possible return by America to actual republican government (the far more likely prognosis being authoritarian rule). Among them, he lists the abandonment of a standing military, because the maintenance of such a force entails exactly what the republican form excludes: a permanent Power with the means of coercion and extraction. Bertrand de Jouvenel explains this in detail in On Power, which Macintyre has often cited as an essential work of political theory. But as de Jouvenel also understood, maintaining standing armies becomes inevitable for any state whose competitors also have them. In the modern global strategic-security environment, there is no way for any top-tier power (as opposed, that is, to vassal states that outsource their security to greater powers) safely not to maintain them. I’m surprised MacIntyre didn’t mention this.
Leaving that minor point aside, the episode is well worth your time. You can find the podcast version here, or the video here.