Ressentiment En France

Theodore Dalrymple, who has spent a working lifetime examining “life at the bottom“, has just published a brief and insightful article on the roots of Muslim unrest in France, and its opportunistic exploitation by provocateurs of the Left.

An excerpt:

Islam, unfortunately, seems to be a religion ill-adapted to minority status because it so successfully instils in its adherents the strong conviction that it represents the final and absolute truth, even when those adherents are not themselves highly observant or do not even know much else about their religion. This conviction leads to a certain sense of superiority or disdain of other cultures and religions, but at the same time those who feel it find themselves in a subordinate and socially and economically inferior situation in most practical aspects.

Subordination and social and economic inferiority are rarely pleasant, particularly if there is a coexistent feeling of moral, religious and civilisational superiority. These conditions are therefore thought to be unjust and anomalous, standing as evidence that the society that permits them is malicious, or at the very least evilly disposed towards Muslims. They thus feel no loyalty to the country in which they live, and can become actively hostile towards it, even or especially when they are completely dependent on it.

Deep resentment is the natural accompaniment to all this, and unfortunately there are political entrepreneurs only too willing to take advantage of and magnify it. For electoral purposes, they assiduously propound the idea that, both on economic and racial grounds, French society is profoundly and irredeemably unjust, and will remain so until the present order is overthrown. Thus, far-left militant secularists are able to join with those who detest the official laicity of the state.

The Mephistophelian leaders of the left in France (such as Jean-Luc Mélenchon and the Mayor of Saint-Denis, Bally Bagayoko) do not promote violence in so many words; they call for peaceful, if continual and disruptive, protest, while at the same time saying that they understand why violence breaks out and that it is as inevitable as a geological event. And, as they conceive themselves romantically as heirs to the French Revolution (as well as to the revolutions of 1830 and 1848, and to the Paris Commune of 1871), they often say that political violence is sometimes justified. A pseudo-syllogism easily develops: Political violence is sometimes justified; we are politically violent; therefore, we are justified.

Dalrymple is always worth your time. Read the rest here.

6 Comments

  1. Jason says

    Hope you and your better half are enjoying Rome, Malcolm. Maybe this time you can see the fountains.

    Something struck me in the Dalrymple essay, how crime is actually lower in Cairo in spite of the dreadful squalor there. At its best religion (in this case Islam) provides a certain dignity to individuals’ lives, a quality that is obviously lacking in the much more wealthy West. Unless we can recover that spiritual capacity it seems to me that any other step we may take to improve things will be cosmetic, like putting a Bandaid on a gaping wound.

    Posted October 28, 2026 at 5:25 pm | Permalink
  2. Malcolm says

    An interesting observation, Jason.

    It raises the question: what is absent in the modern West that is present in the group that Dalrymple describes?

    Posted October 28, 2026 at 5:28 pm | Permalink
  3. Another Dave says

    In their own societies, Muslims will not tolerate the type and scale of crime that Muslim migrants, and their children, feel entitled to commit in Western nations.

    Of course, until relatively recently, and certainly before WWII, Western societies also did not tolerate the kind of degeneracy and violence that is so common now in most urban areas in most Western nations.

    Criminality and degeneracy has been normalized in the West over the past 50 years, and millions of Muslims are more than happy to take advantage of such leniency, all the while despising Europeans and Americans for tolerating such insanity in the first place.

    Posted October 29, 2026 at 12:57 am | Permalink
  4. JMSmith says

    Malcolm asks Jason what source of individual dignity “is absent in the modern West.” Jason had said, rather vaguely, that it was a “spiritual capacity” that Islam provides and “the much more wealthy West” does not. I will suggest that the spiritual capacity is missing for the material reason that the West is largely governed by old men and women. The spiritual term is thumos, the materialist term is testosterone.

    I write this as an old man, a carnal if not, I hope, spiritual Boomer. Thumos is sometimes translated as “spiritedness,” sometimes as “rage,” sometimes as “impetuosity.” But it is in every instance opposed to the old man’s (and woman’s) guiding light of caution. When a man reaches the age when further climbing is out of the question, his whole soul shifts to avoiding the risk of a bad fall.

    There is in today’s West a certain amount of swaggering and performative machismo, but I think this strutting manliness is morbid and born of the miasma of an elderly and estrogenic environment. Resentment and ressentiment certainly cause much of the rage we just saw on the streets of France, but I say we also saw the disgusted reaction of young men with thumos to a world that is too timid and tired to feel “rage.”

    Posted October 30, 2026 at 9:59 am | Permalink
  5. Malcolm says

    JMS,

    Interesting thoughts also.

    I’m not sure that our gerontocracy is the problem in itself — in most traditional societies there is deference to the wisdom of the elders — but I do think you correctly point out that the deflation of thumos, the neutralization and banishment of virility, is a big part of the problem.

    Beneath that is an even deeper problem: the loss of belief in transcendent order and in a differentiating telos that arises from the essential qualities we bear as distinct and various aspects of Creation. This, in turn, can be chalked up to the death of religion, and to the great triumphs of radical nominalism and Gnosticism in our fallen era. (That is, the same denial of essence that demands the radical self-creation ex nihilo we see in the sickness of transgenderism, and that shuts off the electrical potential that keeps the human race going.)

    “In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function. We make men without chests and expect of them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.”

    – Lewis, The Abolition of Man

    Posted October 30, 2026 at 2:05 pm | Permalink
  6. JMSmith says

    I think the wisdom of elders was valued when old men were rare. There is more to it than that, but old age had a mystique when very few survived to old age. To have survived suggested divine favor, perhaps even election.

    I agree with what you say about the loss of a transcendent order and telos. Liberalism tells us we can do as we please, but in doing so removes the standard of success. Or rather, it leaves money as the only universal standard of success, money and the hedonic pleasures it can buy. We haven’t altogether forgotten what it means to succeed as a man, but I think young men are particularly conscious that something has been lost. Some young men, at least.

    Posted October 31, 2026 at 5:53 am | Permalink

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*